In Time of Trouble

Notes from the author on writing this book

In Time of Trouble was my prodigal child. By choosing Shane, a troubled young man who was well aware he was messing up his life, I was in fact choosing an anti-hero—one most editors were just not interested in. 

Early on, one editor told me the first part of the book was depressing and people would stop reading. Many editors told me they liked my writing but not my book. So it was a real challenge to write about Shane and his problems in such a way that people would keep reading. 

In Time of Trouble was my third book. It began as a short story called “Two of a Kind” written long before my first book was published, and later grew into a much longer work. 

Authors are a lot like parents—you love each book equally, but since each book is different, your love for each one a little different. 

I love my first book (which has not yet been published) because it was the first. I love Best of Friends because it was such fun to write about Glen. But there is a special place in my heart for In Time of Trouble. After nine books, it is still the most difficult one I have written. 

Where did I find Shane? When I was in school, teaching, and working with youth groups, I knew many kids just like him. They weren’t bad kids. Just bored or frustrated—usually for reasons that had to do with their families or relationships. 

These kids were often intelligent, but they seemed to make poor decisions—skipping classes, failing to turn in homework, acting as if they didn’t care, mouthing off, and raising walls between themselves and anyone who offered to help. 

It was clear to those who cared about them that if they didn’t get a grip, they were going to really mess up their lives. But you had to wait and pray, and hope that if real trouble came, they would seek help. 

I wrote In Time of Trouble in the hope that people might recognize themselves or their friends in Shane, and realize that no matter how badly or how often we mess up, God is always willing to give us a second chance. 
 

 

Questions to Consider or Discuss

1. Pretty well everything in Shane Donahue’s life is going wrong. 
 a. Why do you think Shane became so upset  when he saw that his jacket was torn? 

 b. Did you feel sorry for Shane, or did you think he deserved everything he got? 

 c. Can you think of a time in your life when you felt everything was spinning out of control? If so, how did you get through it?

2. Marietta has dated Shane for some months, but suddenly she decides to dump him. 
 a. Have you been dumped by someone you thought cared for you? If so, how did you feel? 

 b. Have you ever felt you had to end a relationship? What was the most difficult part about doing it? 

3. Shane soon realizes the people he thought were his friends don’t really care about him. 
 a. What did you think about Shane’s decision to turn his back on Marietta and the others?

 b. Have you ever felt the way Shane did in the playground—that you would like to stop the world and go back in time to when life was easier? If so, how did you handle it?

4. Ted eventually decides to run away and Shane considers suicide. 
 a. Do you know kids who have felt trapped the way Ted and Shane do? What kind of decisions have they made?

 b. Have you ever felt this way? If so, how did you resolve your frustration? 

 c. What do you think might happen to Ted if he stays away? 

 d. What about Keith and Scott? What do you think of the way they are handling their lives? 

5. Shane and Sandy seem to have nothing in common except being identical twins. 
 a. Can you think of anything Sandy could have done to keep the wall between himself and Shane from getting so big? 

 b. What could their parents have done? 

 c. Have you ever drifted away from someone you used to be close to? How did you try to resolve the situation?

 d. In the end, Shane tells Sandy that they had to drift apart so Shane could discover who he is—and that he is different from Sandy. Can you think of a way Shane could have discovered who he is without going through all the pain? 

6. Janice seems to be looking for thrills more than a relationship. 
 a. Do you know kids like this—who are seeking excitement and don’t really know what they’re getting into?

 b. What do you think might satisfy Janice? 

 c. Do you think Sandy was smart to date Janice to learn more about Shane, or was he just asking for trouble?

 d. How would you compare Janice, Marietta, Alicia, and Shane’s mom?

7. Shane basically gives his life to God because he doesn’t know what else to do. 
 a. He was already stealing from his mother, lying, and getting into alcohol and drugs. If he hadn’t turned to God, what do you think would have happened to him? 

 b. Have you known anyone who did the same as Shane—gave their life to God because they had nothing to lose? Do you think God honors their decision as much as that of someone who understand what he or she is doing? 

 c. Do you know any people who would have to be at the end of their ropes before they would turn to God? How could you reach out to them? 

8. Shane gets frustrated with himself because even though he is trying to change, he messes up. Then he wonders if God will turn his back on him. 
 a. Have you ever felt you had blown it and God wouldn’t want anything more to do with you? 

 b. What would you say to someone who came to you and said they can’t be good enough for God? 

 c. Can you think of a time when someone made fun of you or turned away from you because you have a relationship with God? How did you handle it?

9. Shane is shocked when his mother turns to him for help, and then later when his father forbids him to go to church. 
 a. Can you think of something a member of your family said or did that shocked you? 

 b. How should we react when someone close to us says or does something unexpected? 

 c. What do you think of the way Shane handled his father’s order not to go to church? 

10. Shane and Scott and Keith seem to take girls like Marietta and Janice for granted.
 a. Can you think of people you know who  use other people for their own purposes and don’t seem to be bothered by it? 

 b. Why do you think these people act like this? Why would the other people allow themselves to be used? 

11. In the beginning of the book, Shane thought he was all alone. Yet in the end, many people are there to help him. 
 a. How many people can you remember who  helped Shane? 

 b. If you needed help, who do you think you could count on to be there for you?

bar.jpg (2841 bytes)

Best of Friends

Home